Managing Team Conflict by Embracing Creative Disagreement

César Gamio

What is creative disagreement? 

Creative disagreement is a dynamic and constructive exchange of conflicting ideas or viewpoints within a collaborative setting. It goes beyond mere opposition, encompassing a process where individuals engage in thoughtful and innovative discussions, contributing diverse perspectives to solve problems or generate new ideas. In a context of creative disagreement, participants focus on the substance of ideas rather than personal conflicts, fostering an environment where differences are valued as opportunities for learning and growth. 

The goal is not just resolution but the exploration of alternative possibilities and the synthesis of unique insights. This form of disagreement stimulates creativity, challenges conventional thinking and encourages a collective pursuit of innovative solutions.

Embracing conflict in the workplace

In the pursuit of creative breakthroughs and profound insights, people are bound to have differing opinions and dealing with conflict in a team can easily become problematic, so it is essential to embrace the concept of conflicting opinions in the creative process. Embracing conflict means encouraging employees to participate in discussions that may challenge their opinions. This is more than simply building the confidence of individuals who would normally shy away from conflict; it’s about putting a system in place in which conflicting opinions can be presented and explored to maximise productivity, creativity and development, and not to cause offence. For this to succeed, it’s crucial to reframe our perception of conflict and recognise its potential for driving innovation and exceptional outcomes.

Managing team conflict effectively drives healthy disagreement, which can bring out the best in people and foster exceptional ideas:

The key is to view conflict as essential because that’s how we know the best ideas will be tested and survive. It is management’s job to figure out how to help others see conflict as healthy—as a route to balance, which benefits us all in the long run.

Brad Bird, American Filmmaker and Animator

Having worked on a wide array of animated projects such as, The Incredibles, The Incredibles 2, Family Dog, The Simpsons, Ratatouille etc. it’s safe to say that Bird might know a thing or two about embracing creative disagreement, and considering the fact that you probably know at least one of the hugely successful animations on that list, then we should certainly pay close attention to his view that conflict is an essential part of the creative process.

It isn’t just Bird who thinks conflict is necessary for creative excellence, another great example comes from NASA, where decision-making is a critical process. To arrive at the best solutions, some teams at NASA promote healthy conflict by dividing into groups and generating their top five ideas. They then engage in debates to determine the best idea, and each team presents their top choice to others. The process reaches its peak when other groups provide compelling reasons why the selected “top idea” might fail. This approach has been guiding NASA to success for over 61 years. 

To encourage healthy team conflict, consider the following recommendations:

  • Embrace professional conflict: recognise conflict as a constructive tool to encourage team members to view disagreements as opportunities for growth rather than obstacles. Reframe the concept of conflict by fostering an organisational culture that values diverse perspectives, encouraging open dialogue, and emphasising the importance of respectful disagreement as a means to achieve collective success.
  • Avoid taking conflict personally: when ideas are challenged, remind yourself and your team members that the focus is on the substance of the ideas, rather than the individuals presenting them. This helps to create an environment where constructive criticism can thrive, shifting the organisational mindset to allow for a more objective evaluation of ideas. The ultimate goal is to foster a workplace culture where feedback is given and received without personal animosity.
  • Promote respectful conflict: create an environment that welcomes conflict as a creative strategy. Ensure that people participate respectfully by setting clear rules of engagement that will help to create a psychologically safe space where individuals feel comfortable expressing their viewpoints. By achieving this, you will cultivate a culture where healthy conflict becomes a driving force for continuous improvement.
  • Be aware of the impact of conflict on people: some team members may feel uneasy after intense discussions. Provide coaching support to help individuals navigate conflicting emotions and process their experiences. Encourage open communication about feelings, and offer guidance on constructive ways to handle disagreement that ensures team members are not only resilient in the face of conflict but also motivated to contribute to future discussions.

To facilitate and promote the practice of constructive disagreement in the creative process, you can implement various practices and procedures to create a psychologically safe and collaborative work environment. 

Here are some effective practices to promote collaborative conflict resolution:

  • Establish open communication channels: encourage open and transparent communication within the team. Ensure that team members feel comfortable expressing their ideas, opinions, and concerns without fear of judgement or reprisal.
  • Create mind mapping sessions: organise mind mapping sessions where team members can freely share ideas and build on each other’s suggestions. Encourage an open-minded approach to exploring various possibilities.
  • Set ground rules for debates: establish ground rules for debates to ensure that discussions remain respectful and focused on ideas rather than personal attacks. Encourage active listening and discourage any form of disrespect.
  • Encourage diverse teams: form teams with diverse backgrounds, experiences, and expertise. This diversity can lead to a broader range of ideas and perspectives, enhancing the creative potential of the group.
  • Provide training on emotional intelligence: offer training and workshops on emotional intelligence to help team members better understand and manage their emotions during conflicts and disagreements.
  • Conduct after-action reviews: after completing projects or making important decisions, conduct after-action reviews to reflect on the process. Encourage team members to discuss what went well and what could be improved, including how conflicts were managed.

By incorporating these principles and promoting an environment of healthy team conflict… 

…you can unlock your team’s creative potential and drive exceptional outcomes in your workplace. Consider integrating workplace wellbeing programmes and seeking the assistance of wellbeing consultants to support your team’s emotional health and productivity throughout this process. Moreover, managing team conflict effectively supports conflict management between employees, which helps setting the foundation for constructive disagreement and healthy, growth-oriented discussion in the workplace. 

Investing in a psychologically safe workplace that welcomes constructive disagreement not only promotes a culture of trust and collaboration but also serves as a catalyst for continuous growth, innovation, and ultimately, organisational success. Embracing diverse viewpoints creates an environment where individuals feel empowered to contribute their best ideas, paving the way for creative solutions and sustained excellence in the ever-evolving landscape of the professional world.

For more information about how the consultancy service at Dharma Centre for Wellbeing can guide you towards improved workplace wellbeing and enhanced productivity, visit our consultancy page. 

Our blog

Lastest blog posts

Tool and strategies modern teams need to help their companies grow.

Discover how to drive performance through workplace wellbeing